Fallacy 2 of 4

0% complete

P002Epistemic Principles

Also known as: Gendlin's Litany

Difficulty 2/10Low LoadRare

What is true is already so. Owning up to it does not make it worse. Not being open about it does not make it go away. This litany, from psychologist Eugene Gendlin, is a reminder that reality is not waiting for your permission. The things you are afraid to look at are already happening -- and you are already enduring them. Seeing them clearly is not what makes them hard. It is what makes them addressable.

Examples

Loading examples...

We often treat knowledge as though it creates problems rather than reveals them. There is a deep human tendency to confuse the messenger with the message -- to feel that if we just do not look, the thing is not quite real yet. This made a kind of sense in environments where information was scarce and threats were physical. But in most of our lives now, the cost of not knowing is higher than the cost of knowing. Without this practice, we delay, we avoid, we let problems compound in the dark. The Litany of Gendlin is a gentle reminder that you are already living with whatever is true. The only question is whether you are living with it clearly or not.

When you are avoiding information because knowing would feel worse than not knowing, and you need a reminder that the thing is already real
When you notice yourself treating a conversation as dangerous -- as though saying a thing out loud would make it true in a way it was not before
When you sense that a group is collectively pretending something is fine, and you want the courage to gently name what everyone already feels
When you are stuck in a loop of worry, and the litany can help you shift from 'what if it is true' to 'it is already what it is, and I can deal with what is'

You find yourself treating the act of learning something as though it would make the thing more real -- as though not knowing is a kind of protection
You catch yourself thinking 'I do not want to know' and can feel that the not-knowing is doing something for you emotionally, even though it is not doing anything practically
Someone tries to tell you something difficult and your first impulse is to stop them, change the subject, or minimize it
You notice a gap between what you suspect is true and what you are willing to say out loud, and the gap feels load-bearing -- like the silence is holding something in place

Using the litany to justify delivering hard truths to other people without care or kindness -- Gendlin's point is about your own courage to face reality, not a license to be blunt with others
Applying it to speculative futures rather than present realities -- 'what is true is already so' is about what is, not about what might be
Confusing 'what is true' with 'what I believe is true' -- the litany invites you to look more carefully, not to treat your current beliefs as settled

Litany of Gendlin
What is true is already so. Owning up to it doesn't make it worse. Not being open about it doesn't make it go away. And because it's true, it is what is there to be interacted with. Anything untrue isn't there to be lived. People can stand what is true, for they are already enduring it.
Provides courage to face difficult truths by recognizing that reality is already what it is regardless of our acknowledgment. The act of seeing clearly doesn't create problems - it reveals existing ones that can then be addressed. From psychologist Eugene Gendlin.
Litany of TarskiLitany of Occam

Hover to see definition, click to view full details